The Short-Lived State of Deseret: America’s Forgotten Theocracy
Before Utah became a U.S. state, Mormon settlers led by Brigham Young attempted to carve out their own nation—the ambitious but little-known State of Deseret.
In the aftermath of their harrowing exodus from persecution in the Midwest, thousands of Mormon pioneers, members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, journeyed westward under the guidance of Brigham Young. Their destination was the Great Basin, a remote and barren region far beyond the jurisdiction of the United States in 1847. By 1849, these settlers had transformed a small outpost near the Great Salt Lake into a fledgling community, but their vision extended far beyond a single colony.
That same year, Young and his closest advisors drafted a constitution for the “State of Deseret,” a name taken from Mormon scripture meaning “honeybee” and meant to embody industriousness. In their proposed state, the borders stretched from parts of modern-day California, Nevada, Arizona, New Mexico, and Colorado, forming a massive swath of the West that nearly equaled Texas in size. The capital would be Salt Lake City. The new government, a blend of theocracy and democracy, intended to allow considerable autonomy while establishing laws rooted in Mormon doctrine. Deseret’s leaders soon sent a delegation to Washington, D.C., petitioning Congress to recognize their new state.
The U.S. government, though impressed by Deseret’s organization, was wary. In the wake of the Mexican-American War, the United States had just acquired the vast territory encompassing much of the West through the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo. The federal government was eager to impose its own controls and was reluctant to create a state effectively governed by a religious group with controversial beliefs and practices such as polygamy. Moreover, Deseret’s borders encompassed potentially lucrative lands, including parts of what would later be California’s gold fields. The religious and political independence the Mormons sought was simply too much for Congress to accept.
Despite their rejection in Washington, the leaders of Deseret acted as if approval was imminent. For over a year, the State of Deseret functioned almost like an independent nation. It had its own laws, courts, and even a militia. City officials, judges, and other government officers were selected by a group of elders and then ratified by popular vote among the settlers. Church and civil leadership often overlapped, with Brigham Young serving as both governor and spiritual head.
Life in Deseret was not easy. The region was harsh and isolated, requiring careful cooperation to survive. Laws criminalized alcohol, gambling, and other activities viewed as immoral by the church. Taxes were paid largely in kind—wheat, livestock, and other essentials. Roads, irrigation systems, and schools were rapidly constructed. The local economy was monitored by church-appointed town councils, and each settlement practiced communal assistance.
Despite their efforts, the challenges from the outside world became increasingly difficult to ignore. The discovery of gold in California brought a flood of settlers and fortune-seekers pouring through Mormon lands. Tensions with indigenous populations and the arrival of non-Mormon settlers further complicated matters. Mormon leaders were forced to strike a delicate balance between maintaining autonomy and participating in the growing economies and geopolitics of the expanding United States.
In 1850, the standoff ended with the creation of the Utah Territory, forced by the Compromise of 1850. The boundaries shrank dramatically, and Utah was placed under federal oversight, though Brigham Young was appointed territorial governor. The State of Deseret quietly faded away, its unofficial government dissolved, though many customs and elements of self-governance survived. Official documents issued during Deseret’s brief existence, including currency and laws, remain rare and highly sought by historians today.
The story of the State of Deseret is rarely told beyond Utah and among scholars, yet it represents a little-known chapter of American nation-building: a theocratic experiment reaching beyond statehood, born of necessity and faith, subsumed by the tides of westward expansion and federal authority.
###END###
