The Forgotten Presidential Election of 1876
The 1876 election nearly sparked a constitutional crisis, deciding the U.S. presidency through secret backroom deals.
In the waning days of the 19th century, the United States faced its most disputed presidential election. The year was 1876, and the country was still reeling from the Civil War and the turbulent period of Reconstruction. Republican Rutherford B. Hayes and Democrat Samuel J. Tilden found themselves at the center of a political storm that would not only shape the presidency but also determine the fate of Southern states and the trajectory of civil rights for decades to come.
On election night, November 7, 1876, early returns suggested Tilden, the reforming governor of New York, would easily win. He secured 184 electoral votes, just one shy of the 185 needed to win outright, while Hayes had 165. However, 20 electoral votes from four states—Florida, Louisiana, South Carolina, and Oregon—remained in dispute due to widespread allegations of fraud, intimidation, and conflicting certifications of the results.
Republicans and Democrats each claimed victory in the disputed states, and two sets of electoral votes were submitted for each: one favoring Hayes, the other Tilden. The U.S. Constitution lacked clear instructions for handling such a crisis, and tensions flared nationwide. Reports of possible armed insurrection circulated, and some states openly discussed secession again.
To prevent chaos, Congress established a special Electoral Commission, composed of 15 members: five from the House, five from the Senate, and five Supreme Court justices. The expectation was for the Commission’s composition to favor neutrality, but political maneuvering tipped it in favor of the Republicans. In an anxious series of votes, the Commission awarded all 20 contested electoral votes to Hayes, handing him a razor-thin victory of 185 to 184.
Behind closed doors, however, the matter was settled not by law, but by negotiation in what became known as the Compromise of 1877. Southern Democrats agreed to accept Hayes as president. In return, Republicans promised to withdraw federal troops from the South, effectively ending Reconstruction and abandoning federal enforcement of Civil Rights for African Americans. This deal ushered in “home rule” in the South and allowed for the rise of Jim Crow laws—a legacy that would persist well into the 20th century.
Rarely taught in schools and not commemorated in public memory, the election of 1876 is one of the closest and most controversial in American history. It underscored the inherent vulnerabilities of the electoral process and set precedents for backroom political bargaining. More crucially, it marked a turning point that reshaped race relations and power structures throughout the country for generations, the reverberations of which are still felt today.
###END###
