Title: The Forgotten Uprising of the Pennsylvania Dutch
In 1763, the Pennsylvania Dutch launched a forgotten uprising known as the Paxton Boys Uprising.
Tensions in colonial Pennsylvania reached a boiling point in December 1763 when a group of settlers, primarily Scots-Irish immigrants calling themselves the “Paxton Boys,” banded together to address their grievances through violent means. This event remains a less-known chapter of American history, highlighting the complexities of colonial frontier life and the interplay of various ethnic and social tensions.
Colonial Pennsylvania was a mosaic of diverse cultures and communities, including English, German, Scots-Irish, and several Native American tribes. The Germans, or “Deutsch,” misheard as “Dutch,” comprised a significant portion of the rural population, particularly in areas like Lancaster County. Among these were the settlers who would later be involved in the Paxton Boys movement.
The immediate catalyst for the uprising was the Native American attacks along the western frontier. Many colonists felt threatened and unprotected, as the provincial government, led by Quaker lawmakers, was perceived as too lenient toward Native American tribes. This lax attitude was due to the Quakers’ strong ideological commitment to pacifism and fair treatment of all peoples, including Native Americans.
However, the frontier settlers, including the Paxton Boys, bore the brunt of the hostilities and felt that their plight was ignored. They demanded more protection and a stronger military response to Native American raids. Their requests repeatedly dismissed, the group took matters into their own hands, leading to a tragic and gruesome act that would ignite the uprising.
In late 1763, the Paxton Boys descended upon Conestoga, a small community where a number of Susquehannock Indians had lived peacefully for years under the protection of the Pennsylvania government. Believing the Susquehannocks to be allies of hostile tribes, the Paxton Boys massacred six Susquehannocks and burned their village. When they learned that some of the Susquehannock had sought refuge in Lancaster, the Paxton Boys broke into the Lancaster workhouse and brutally killed the remaining fourteen.
This massacre sparked a significant outcry across the colonies, especially among those in the government and religious leaders who saw the attacks as barbaric and unjust. However, it also drew support from other frontier settlers who felt similarly disenfranchised.
Following the massacres, the Paxton Boys marched towards Philadelphia in January 1764, intending to confront the colonial government. Their force had grown to about 250 men. Fearing the group’s arrival, Benjamin Franklin met them in Germantown, just outside Philadelphia. Franklin, a skilled negotiator, managed to calm the tensions by promising to listen to their grievances, effectively averting an attack on the capital.
Subsequently, the colonial government took steps to address some of the frontier concerns, but the deep-seated issues between different ethnic and cultural groups remained. The Paxton Boys Uprising not only illustrates the harsh realities of frontier life but also reflects the complexities of colonial politics, the diversity of its peoples, and the continual negotiation between peace and violence on the American frontier.
This uprising is often overshadowed by other colonial conflicts and revolutionary activities that followed, yet it is a poignant reminder of the inner conflicts and divisions that shaped the early American society and contributed to the broader patterns of American history.
###END###
